Australian Arts Review
Bill Stephens
THE TALES OF HOFFMANN - Opera Australia
Jessica Pratt more than satisfies the high expectations placed on her in interpreting Hoffmann’s four loves. Not only is her singing exquisite throughout, but she’s also a convincing actress, and the added panache she exhibits in executing several daunting physical challenges created by Michieletto’s concept, sets the bar almost impossibly high for any soprano succeeding her in these roles.
Among them, she’s required to balance on a school desk impersonating a mechanical doll while being pushed around the stage during an uproarious schoolroom scene; and execute several frighteningly realistic falls as a dying ballerina in a sequence seemingly inspired by the famous Moira Shearer film of this opera.
Australian Book Review
Michael Halliwell
The Tales of Hoffmann - A fascinating production of Offenbach’s classic
Pratt reveals crystal-clear coloratura facility as the automaton Olympia in Act One. Perhaps Pratt’s ornamentation of the second verse of the famous ‘Doll Song’ is the robot disobeying its master – has AI become too powerful and unruly? It certainly can be seen as a tale for our times.
Diametrically opposed are the vocal demands of Antonia. Here Pratt demonstrates the true quality of her remarkable instrument, with a luscious warmth and gleam to the tone; her vast experience in the bel canto repertoire is very apparent in her effortless ability to spin a beautiful vocal line. As Giulietta, she employs a more dramatic edge to the tone; Pratt’s voice rode majestically over chorus and orchestra in the sextet that ends the act. This is a performance of supreme quality.
J-Wire
Murray Dahm
The Tales of Hoffmann
I am in danger of using the word magnificent too many times in this review, so I will attempt to keep it to just the once – to describe the performance of Jessica Pratt as all four heroines (Olympia, Antonia, Giulietta, and Stella). These four roles are individually fiendish and to have an artist perform all four with such skill is, truly, a once in a life-time experience. Offenbach wrote all four roles intending that they be performed by the same singer (Olympia, Antonia and Giulietta represent different aspects of the soul of Stella). The four are so different, however, (Olympia a coloratura, Antonia more lyric and Giulietta more dramatic (she has even been performed by mezzo sopranos) that it did not take long for them to be split among different singers. Having them reunited in the same artist (as Offenbach intended) is thoroughly satisfying. What is more, Pratt showed why a great artist should encompass all four. Her Olympia was glorious, the doll of the production was lifelike (moulded after Pratt’s likeness rather than the other way around) and her vocal pyrotechnics in The Doll’s Song (‘Les oiseaux dans la charmille’) brought the house down, as well it should have. The top of her voice was clean and vibrant (and, quite frankly, a wonder in its own right) and it rang out as few other voices in the Sydney Opera House have in my experience. What is more, she was required to sing the second verse of the famous aria being wheeled around (albeit carefully) upon a desk. It is hard enough to sing such an aria standing still let alone on the move.
However, the dramatic sincerity of the Antonia act which followed was even more wondrous. Pratt sang the rêverie ‘Elle a fui, la tourterelle’ beautifully and this set up, for me, the dramatic core of the evening. As the disabled Antonia, no longer able to dance, and with the aid of wheelchair and crutches, it was completely convincing that Pratt had lost the use of her legs. To be able to sing (and, at the same time, by necessity, be grounded and supported to be able to sing) whilst making it appear that her legs no longer worked brought me to tears. The tragedy of the act (where Antonia sacrifices her life for art, manipulated by the villain, Dr Miracle) was astonishing. Here then, not only was the singing uniformly superb but the acting and dramatic truth were complete. As Giulietta, in gold lamé and blonde, she was the seductress the courtesan Giulietta needs to be. One of the many changes to Offenbach’s original scheme for the opera is that the order of the acts can be changed. Each is based partially on a short story by the poet E.T.A Hoffmann (the eponymous hero of the opera) and so, for the most part each act is not affected by the placement of the others. Thus, you will find the acts of the opera in different orders (and even with different names). In this production, they are presented in Offenbach’s original order – prologue, Act I (Olympia), Act II (Antonia), Act III (Giulietta), Epilogue. This production reveals why this order makes the most sense (although you will still find productions where the order is Olympia, Giulietta, Antonia).
Simon Parris
Simon Parris
Opera Australia: The Tales of Hoffmann review [Sydney 2023]
In a towering performance that seems always destined to have been achieved, Jessica Pratt triumphs in the full suite of Hoffmann heroines. From the extended ovation for the soaring, meticulously controlled “Doll Aria” of Olympia, Pratt continues through the heartrending plight of Antonia, and on to the coquettish duplicity of Giulietta. Exquisite coloratura and stunning interpolated high notes are hallmarks of Pratt in peak form, the stunning musicality of her performance matched by the impact of her success in a range of acting styles, from mechanised doll to tragic dancer to kittenish vixen. This is a highly memorable performance to be treasured, talked about, and boasted over for having seen.
Sydney Morning Herald
Peter McCallum
The Tales of Hoffmann
Pratt manages to give her heroines discrete vocal and dramatic personas. As Olympia, the automaton, she sings the Doll Song with unwavering precision, each note stamped out like a mechanical pearl, but a pearl nevertheless. As Antonia, the doomed soprano fatally attracted to forbidden music, her voice is laced with tragic heaviness, while as Giulietta she underscores the suavity of Belle nuit, o nuit d’amour with a hint of sultry darkness.
City Hub
Rita Bratovich
The Tales of Hoffman – REVIEW
The four female leads: Olympia, Antonia, Giulietta, Stella are often played by different singers, but in rare instances, when an extraordinary artist is available, the roles are all sung by the one soprano. For this production, audiences are blessed with the other-worldly voice of home-grown international diva, Jessica Pratt.
Pratt’s stunning rendition of “Les Oiseaux Dans La Charmille” (The Birds In The Bower) as Olympia draws a very lengthy and loud applause which would have been a standing ovation if most of the audience wasn’t encumbered by miscellany on their laps...
Backtrack
David Larkin
Twists in the tales: Michieletto brings Offenbach’s Hoffmann to life
Much of the fanfare beforehand was about Jessica Pratt, the Australian star soprano who has forged a stellar career overseas in the big bel canto roles. Playing all three of the hero’s past love interests, and Stella, his present-day inamorata, she grew in stature over the evening. Her rendering of the fiendish coloratura in Olympia’s doll aria was very fine if not entirely flawless; Antonia allowed her to show off her cantabile, and she reached new heights as Giulietta.
One of Opera Australia’s best productions in many a long year, this Hoffmann is lavish, imaginative fun. Go see it before the run closes.
Arts Hub
Gina Fairley
Opera review: The Tales of Hoffmann, Sydney Opera House
Kicking off the world premiere, internationally celebrated, home-grown soprano, Jessica Pratt has returned to Australia to perform the lead role – well, all four of them – a gong afforded to few performers. Her performance has already had critics mentioning Dame Joan Sutherland’s 1975 performance as a comparison.
While Pratt’s “mechanical” gestures as Olympia in the first act need a bit of a Michael Jackson moonwalk injection, her focus is steadfast, and her soulful lament as Antonia in the second act, twisted physically and emotionally in pain, is sublime. And, it goes without saying, she is right at home in the calculating character of Giulietta.
City News
Helen Musa
‘Hoffmann’ opera goes off on a bender
And above all, nobody could doubt the extraordinary prowess of Australian soprano Jessica Pratt in the roles of four different women, for the opera is essentially a vehicle for singers possessed of her coloratura brilliance. She must from now on be the go-to person for this role.
Limelight
Deborah Jones
The Tales of Hoffmann (Opera Australia) Jessica Pratt and Iván Ayón Rivas head a superb cast in Damiano Michieletto’s thrilling production of Offenbach’s last, greatest opera.
Jessica Pratt was the calm centre of the storm. The composure with which Pratt dispatched the first of her four heroines was extraordinary as she scattered brilliant stratospheric notes (up to a high F) around the room while standing on a desk.
Stage Noise
Diana Simmonds
THE TALES OF HOFFMANN
And Pratt is spectacular, vocally and as an actor, making the different characters easy to pick even amid the production’s energetic confusion.